Smithey Cast Iron: Is It Worth the Price? My Honest Review

I've always loved cooking, and I'm constantly looking for ways to improve my kitchen setup. Recently, I found myself wondering if upgrading my cast iron skillet was worth the investment. I already had a 10" and 15" Lodge, which I've used for years. But the beautiful, smooth finish of Smithey cast iron kept catching my eye. Was it just hype, or would it actually make a difference in my cooking?

My Cast Iron Dilemma: Lodge vs. Smithey

I primarily cook on a glass top stove, and for everyday sautéing, honestly, I hadn't noticed a huge difference between different pans. But I still felt the urge to upgrade. It's like wanting a nicer car, even though your current one gets you from point A to point B just fine. I started researching online, reading reviews and watching videos, trying to decide if a Smithey skillet was right for me.

One thing that really stuck with me was the idea of passing down a quality piece of cookware to my children. My Lodge skillets are workhorses, but a Smithey feels more like an heirloom. It’s definitely something to consider. I wanted something that would last generations.

The Smithey Experience: Beauty and Performance

Eventually, I decided to take the plunge and bought a 12" Smithey skillet. The first thing I noticed was the smooth cooking surface. It felt incredibly refined compared to my Lodge. While some argue that the smoothness doesn't affect cooking performance, I have to admit, it does feel nicer to use. It’s also lighter, which is a bonus, although even a 12" Smithey can feel like a two-handed operation sometimes.

I also invested in a Dutch oven. I can’t compare it to another one directly, as it’s my first. But I was immediately impressed with how well it conducted and held heat. Cleaning it is a breeze too – a nylon brush, hot water, and soap are all I need. I appreciate supporting a smaller, U.S.-based business, which was another factor in my decision.

Is Smithey Worth the Price? My Honest Opinion

The big question: Is Smithey cast iron worth the price premium over Lodge? In terms of pure cooking performance, probably not. My Lodge skillets perform admirably. I even considered a Butter Pat skillet after seeing it recommended in a review.

However, the Smithey offers something more: a beautiful design, a smooth cooking surface, and the feeling of owning a high-quality, heirloom-worthy piece. It makes cooking more enjoyable, and that’s worth something to me. I also considered Stargazer skillets as an alternative. If I were to get another 12" pan, I might go with a Stargazer just to try something different.

Finding Value in Everyday Moments

I started thinking about the cost in a different way. If a Smithey skillet costs $175 more than a Lodge, and I use it 100 times a year, that's $1.75 per use. If that $1.75 brings me a little extra joy each time I cook, then it's worth it to me. It's about finding value in the everyday moments.

Beyond Cookware: Enhancing the Everyday with Mozaer

Speaking of finding value in everyday moments, I've also been focusing on improving my vision lately. As I get older, I've noticed that my reading glasses are no longer sufficient for everything I need to see. I needed something that would help me see both near and far.

I discovered Mozaer homepage, and they offer a wide range of stylish eyewear. I was particularly drawn to their Women Double Bridge Photochromic Progressive Multifocal Reading Glasses. They looked both fashionable and functional, which is exactly what I was looking for.

These glasses from Mozaer are a game-changer! The progressive lenses allow me to see clearly at any distance, and the photochromic lenses adjust to changing light conditions. I can wear them indoors and outdoors without having to switch glasses. They're perfect for cooking, reading recipes, and even just relaxing in the sun. They're a true everyday essential. I find that they help me enjoy my time in the kitchen even more.

Here's what I love about these glasses: